Remove IPs from Outgoing Mail (Postfix SMTP)

Moblog


Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

*Interesting approach - but of course the consequences of your idea have to be checked: how does spam-recognition think about that? How long will it take until your servers are blacklisted with this config and you will be de facto cut off from the world? Any real life experience?
Please report!
#1 Snaky on 2011-01-04 10:44 (Reply)
*Last time I checked, Google Mail also doesn't include the user's IP when using the web interface. There is absolutely no requirement to forward this information to third parties. I have been using the configuration above for a long time now. Why would my server get blacklisted when there is never any spam coming from it?

Also, many users use a relay host, because their own infrastructure is on a dynamic IP, or they don't want to cope with the details of running a public mailserver that basically has to be up 24/7. Removing the 'first incoming IP' is really nothing to be worried about.

An obvious reminder: This will only make you anonymous among the set of users of this mail server. In my case, as the only user of the server, it stops location tracking. It does not make me anonymous.

Most email providers don't want to remove IPs because they don't want to deal with abuse complaints. It would be easy to match message IDs or some inserted random header in case, but it's just too much work for most ISPs.
#1.1 Moritz on 2011-01-04 11:00 (Reply)
*Actually, this PREVENTS overzealous spam filters from blocking your mail.

The rason is that some spam filters mark as spam any mail that has a dynamically-assigned IP address in ANY Received: header. This is obviously wrong if the user of said dynamic IP is authenticated (but arguably sensible if the dynamic IP user is not, as in spambots on infected user PCs).
So, removing the user name and IP for authenticated users is good.
I currently use something a bit more elaborate that leaves the Received: line in but edits out the IP and user name. I found the recipe on the Postfix-Users mailing list.
#1.2 Jan on 2011-12-10 09:23 (Reply)
*> How long will it take until your servers are blacklisted with this config and you will be de facto cut off from the world?

You won't be blacklisted. Many companies use this to hide internal IPs. There is no reason (other than nefarious purposes) for the world+dog to know the internal IP space of an intra-net.

If you blacklisted are then then something is incorrectly configured.
#2 Bob on 2011-02-07 15:40 (Reply)

Choose Language

Twitter

Quicksearch

 

Creative Commons License - Some Rights Reserved

Open Data Network

re:publica 2011 Berlin

Attac

Nachdenkseiten

Tor Exit Node Hosting

datalove Logo